suliman's blog

a guide to the foundation universe

I felt like nerding out and making an easily linkable guide behind whose tips I stand. There are plenty of guides online, but I feel like they overcomplicate things and – most importantly – were written before the show aired. This is both to explain where the show is situated in the long line of books, what’s in the cannon story (basically any new additions that you won’t find in the books), and how I would read the books if I started today. 

When I first dove into this book series, I started by reading them in timeline-chronological order which turned out to be more confusing than experiencing the story how everyone who lived through its publication did. Asimov probably wrote them with the expectation that the people who would pick up the prequels already had the knowledge provided by the main trilogy. After an interruption of almost two years, I decided to start afresh with the original trilogy, read the sequels and then go back to the prequels which released last anyway. That’s what I would recommend to others as well if all you’re after is the Seldon timeline. 

If you want the grand picture, you’ll have to read his Robot series which takes place on the same timeline but in the distant past. If I was starting out with his work now, I would begin my read with this series first and read The Complete Robot, keeping the short story Mirror Image for later because it takes place, chronologically, after The Caves of Steel. The Complete Robot is a short story collection that is supposed to equip you with the context required to understand the role robots occupy in this supposed future society. He goes over the functioning of the “positronic brain” and its responses to various stimuli while also describing how humans felt about robots across the decades and centuries. If you have trouble getting through some of the stories, I would skip them. The only must reads are the Some Humanoid Robots part, Susan Calvin stories, the Segregationist short story, and the Two Climaxes part. Everything else is inessential in my humble opinion.

Anyway, after that the storyline becomes super interesting on one hand (with lots of lore) and on the other takes on the format familiar to most – the novel. The stories follow pretty much the same set of characters across the series which makes it easier to resonate with them. I would read The Caves of Steel and then the Mirror Image short story from The Complete Robot I told you to withhold until now. The Naked SunThe Robots of Dawn, and Robots and Empire introduce a set of characters that will remain relevant even well into the Foundation series, at least in the misty legends of the past. 

This may be an unpopular opinion, but I think his Galactic Empire series is a worthy read. It may not contain stories directly connected to the rest. However, it showcases the dynamics in the galaxy prior to the formation of a Galactic Empire. A Pebble in the Sky is my favorite of the lot, but not any more important than the rest – again, in my opinion. You could also skip these three short novels and not really miss much. Many seem to situate these novels in an in-between between Robots and Foundation. Since they have little direct interaction with the other stories, it’s up to you when you read them. 

Lastly, I would recommend you watch the show – which covers the main trilogy only with the occasional lore from the rest of the universe resurfacing here and there – before or after you’re done reading his books, not while reading! This is very important and the one thing that can make or break your opinion of this entire project. The show is amazing, don’t get me wrong, but nothing – plot-wise – like the books.1 It will all just confuse you. In fact, I would watch itafter reading, if I was you. The show was what got me into the books after all, so maybe it won’t be as bad as I’m making it out to be if you did the same as me. 

The reason for this recommendation is that the show deviates heavily from the source material. I don’t think I’ve ever seen an adaptation veer this far from the source. While the characters and places pretty much hold the same names, the dynamics are different in the most unexpected ways and a lot of it is the consequence of the Genetic Dynasty’s creation and Demerzel’s guardianship of it. The Prime Radiant’s function is also different and some events are modified slightly, but have far reaching effects on the plot. They’re not bad changes per se, just confusing if you read and watch at the same time. Just do yourself a favor and don’t do that.

Here is a list for easier reference of what I think is cannon and the correct reading order:2

  1. The Complete Robot (Segregationist, Some Humanoid Robots, Susan Calvin, Two Climaxes)
  2. The Caves of Steel
  3. Mirror Image from The Complete Robot
  4. The Naked Sun
  5. The Robots of Dawn
  6. Robots and Empire
  7. (The Stars, Like Dust)
  8. (The Currents of Space)
  9. (Pebble in the Sky)3
  10. The original trilogy: Foundation, Foundation and Empire, Second Foundation
  11. Foundation’s Edge
  12. Foundation and Earth
  13. Prelude to Foundation
  14. Forward the Foundation
  15. Apple TV+ adaptation

I would not bother with any other adaptation. The others are a disgrace. Hope this helps new readers and happy reading! PS: There are some other books that are vaguely connected to/situated in the Foundation universe like Mother Earth, The End of Eternity, Nemesis, and The Gods Themselves. I haven’t read those so I don’t know yet when it would be best to read them. I’ll update this list once I got there (although I don’t expect to read Mother Earth because it belongs to a collection I can’t find much info about).

  1. Mainly because the original trilogy was written in the 40s and made into a trilogy in the early 50s.

  2. I actually read everything in reverse. Watched the show, then read the Foundation series, then the Galactic Empire, and lastly the Robot series. Though, I wish I hadn’t done that. I just didn’t expect for science fiction written so far in the past to be this good.

  3. Out of all the Galactic Empire books, I would highly recommend reading at least Pebble in the Sky, even though you could skip the series altogether. The context and feel provided in this story is still valuable for understanding the politics described in the other books. The book is mostly about the Galactic Empire’s treatment of Earth (which was bullied by the Spacers and later by the Settlers).